Re: ? Comyn spouse of Malise

Regarding Comyn child who had been spouse from Malise of Strathearn, I experienced theorized when you look at the 2005 you to she had been Margaret, identified as wife away from Sir John de Keith (find content out of article below) who was simply 2ndly age are provided where post: new wife Emma I would suggest was of some other nearest and dearest, and not mother of next Earl Malise.

Scots Peerage, sub _Comyn, Earl of Buchan_ , says partly, ‘Malise, Earl from Strathearn, got a spouse Emma, in the 1261-1267, whoever surname are unknown ‘[SP II:256, cites Cal. regarding Docs., we. 2383, 2451]. a little while just before 1270, in order that his widow (Margaret) could have been “available” some time shortly after Emma.

It was without a doubt a speculation; it will feel the advantageous asset of coping with a known dating ranging from Muriel Keith and Reginald ce Cheyne. Anymore related files carry out obviously be welcome.

The fresh new account inside Scots Peerage about the class of Keith claims regarding Sir John de- Keith (d. california. 1270) that he are said to has actually hitched Comyn, earl out of Buchan . This identification, of your unsure (“thought to had been”) variety, can getting fixed in line with the after the dispensation, dated from the Fondi towards the fourteen Jan 1378/9::

‘ Reg Aven 215, 50 Into the bishop out-of Moray. Professors to distribute Reginald Cheyn, donzel, and you can Murielle, damselle, d de Keth, off Moray and you may Aberdeen dioceses, regarding the impediment to help you relationships due to the third and you will 4th levels of consanguinity. Fondi, 19 Kal. Feb., anno 1. SRO Vat. Trans., iv, no. 46. ‘

Muriel Keith, the long run next wife out of Robert Stewart, very first Duke from Albany (d. 1420), is actually developed to help you get married Reginald le Cheyne, young man out-of Sir Reginald le Cheyne from the their spouse (as their own basic spouse), Helen out of Strathearn. While there are distinguished holes on the origins out-of Muriel Keith, she and Reginald le Cheyne would share an origin regarding the Comyns. Yet not, this might be as well faraway to require a beneficial dispensation if the Muriel is a beneficial-great-high grandd Comyn, Earl out of Buchan (d. 1233), which could end up being the instance when the is the reason child.

dos. Reginald ce Cheyne are an excellent-grandson of Marjory Comyn, child off Alexander Comyn, Earl of Buchan (d. 1290), young man regarding William Comyn in the list above. Her young buck try Malise, Earl out of Strathearn of 1312 in order to his passing during the 1328 , and you can parent out-of Reginald.

california. 1270), is just like Marjory Comyn, and you can hitched 2ndly to help you Malise, Earl of Strathearn (d. 1312). This should suggest new parentage a€?thought to have been’ compared to Margaret, wife out of Sir John de Keith, is from you to age group: she would not have become the fresh new d Comyn, Earl of Buchan, but instead out of their young buck Alexander. There is absolutely no facts one to Earl Malise and you may Marjory Comyn was indeed married far prior to 1275: given that Lindsay authored,

There is one discernable basis on what the partnership ranging from Reginald ce Cheyne and you may Muriel Keith could have resided: if the Margaret Comyn, wife away from Sir John de Keith (d

‘ The newest wife with the earl, regarding 1275, was entitled Marjory, once we see the attesting is it easy to get married from Salinas, PR women term off Zero. curriculum vitae., that will be mentioned from the Wyntoun, Publication VIII. chap. vi., getting already been the second sister out-of John Comyn, Earl of Buchan, whom discussed for Earl Malise the marriage settlement over said [dated on London, April 26, 1293 to possess his daughter Matilda and you may Robert de- Tony, young buck regarding Ralph].’

Alexander Comyn = Elizabeth de- Quincy Age of Buchan We __________________I________________ I III step 1) Sir John = Marjory = 2) Malise de- Keith I (als We E off Strathearn . 1270 I Margaret) We d. 1312 _____________I__ ___I__________________________ I I We We I We Sir William Bernard Malise Gilbert Robert Maud de Keith de- Keith Elizabeth of = Robert d. bef 1293 Strathearn; d. 1328 de Tony We ______I_______________________ I I I I Sir Edward Malise Mary Helen = Isabella de Age out-of Strathearn = 1) Sir Reginald Synton d. california. 1343 We ce Cheyne We We We = 2) Sir David I V I I de- Graham Sir William de- I I__________ Keith I We = Margaret Fraser __________________I_______ V __I_____________ I We We III We We I We Muriel + Reginald Mary Mariota Keith le Cheyne (= Robert Stewart, Duke off Albany)